Plus 30 minutes for the rub to work, and 8 minutes' rest after cooking.
Before you start. The rub contains sugar, which burns faster than the steak cooks. Use a hot pan, not a screaming one, and take it off the heat the moment the crust is black-brown rather than waiting for a timer.
Coffee on beef sounds like something invented to sell coffee. It is not — it is an old barbecue trick from the American south-west, and the reason it stuck around is that it works better than almost anything else you can put on a steak.
The trick to understanding it is to stop thinking of coffee as a drink for a minute. Ground fine, it is a bitter, dark, intensely aromatic powder. That is a spice. It behaves like one.
What comes out of the pan does not taste of coffee. It tastes like the best crust you have ever got on a steak at home.
What you need
- 2 ribeye or sirloin steaks, around 2.5cm thick, at room temperature
- 2 tbsp Western Tamp Midnight Ride, ground fine
- 1 tbsp dark brown sugar
- 2 tsp flaky sea salt
- 1 tsp smoked paprika
- 1 tsp cracked black pepper
- ½ tsp garlic powder
- 1 tbsp beef dripping, or any oil with a high smoke point
The roast for this Midnight Ride From £11.95 How to make it
-
Mix the rub
Combine the ground coffee, sugar, salt, paprika, pepper and garlic powder. Grind the coffee finer than you would to drink it — espresso fine. Coarse grounds do not stick to the meat and you end up chewing grit.
-
Dry the steaks, then coat them
Pat both steaks completely dry with kitchen paper. This matters more than anything else here — a wet steak steams instead of searing and you will never get a crust. Press the rub onto both sides and the edges.
-
Leave them 30 minutes
At room temperature, uncovered, on a rack if you have one. The salt draws moisture out and then pulls it back in seasoned, and the surface dries out further, which is exactly what you want before it hits the pan.
-
Get the pan hot, but not smoking hard
Heavy pan, medium-high, dripping in. You want it hot enough to sizzle on contact but not so hot that the sugar in the rub scorches in the first thirty seconds. If it starts smoking heavily, pull it off the heat for a moment.
-
Three minutes a side
Lay them away from you and leave them alone. Three minutes, flip once, three minutes for medium-rare on a 2.5cm steak. Use the edge of the pan to sear the fat strip for a minute if there is one.
-
Rest for eight minutes
On a warm plate, loosely covered. Cutting early dumps the juice onto the board. Eight minutes is not optional.
Why it works
This is not about making the steak taste of coffee, and it does not. Finely ground dark roast behaves in a rub the way any strong spice does: it is bitter, tannic and aromatic, and those things read as savoury depth against beef fat rather than as a cup of coffee. The sugar is doing the other job — it caramelises and drives the Maillard reaction faster and further than salt alone can, so you get a genuinely black crust in six minutes on a domestic hob rather than the pale grey-brown most home steaks end up with. Midnight Ride is the right blend for it precisely because it is the darkest thing we roast; the bittersweet chocolate and campfire smoke in the cup are the same notes doing the work on the plate.
Worth knowing
- The rub keeps in a sealed jar for a month and is just as good on pork shoulder, lamb chops, chicken thighs or portobello mushrooms.
- Double the sugar and it becomes a barbecue rub for low and slow — at 110°C it will not burn.
- Do not marinate. This is a dry rub; adding liquid defeats the entire purpose of drying the surface out.
- If you have a meat thermometer, pull at 52°C for medium-rare. Carryover heat takes it to about 55°C while it rests.
More like this
Get it right